Lisbon isn’t just its buildings, restaurants, hotels, sea views, and investment returns. Lisbon, or any city, is memory. It’s family networks, small shops, old neighbours, ordinary routines, language, humour, grief, pride, and continuity.
It becomes a form of exploitation when investors are allowed to bid for a culture nurtured over generations, prune its rough edges, and then sell access to it for maximum profit…rendering it beautiful, but hollow. Meanwhile, those who created much of its value are left with higher rents, weaker communities, and a growing sense that their own country no longer has room for them.
But at least it enriches a narrow class /s
To be clear, the danger isn’t tourism itself. Tourism brings money, jobs, visibility, and cultural exchange. The danger is this modern extractive form of it. And it doesn’t take much imagination to consider the consequences. You’d only need to look at London, Paris, Geneva, among countless others, to notice how wealth preserved the surface while shifting the life beneath it.
I write this seemingly naively, as if private equity and wealthy investors are merely oblivious to the effects of their quarterly goals. Unfortunately, and with great insomnia, I know it’s a business model: privatise the gains and socialise the losses. All enabled by regulatory capture, political incentives, and a dash of scorn that community isn’t as profitable as individual isolationism.
Moral imagination is key, and unfortunately, sparsely executed. I struggle between accepting unwarranted accumulation as an inevitable human impulse, and whether surrendering to that conclusion is a kind of defeat. Greed often feels more powerful than kindness, because it is easier: easier to take than to care, easier to extract than to preserve, easier for a few determined people to damage what many gentler people are trying to protect.
A country shouldn’t measure success only by how much capital it attracts, how much property appreciates, or how many luxury developments appear. It should ask whether one of its young people can afford to live near their family. Whether an elderly resident can remain in the neighbourhood they know. Whether workers in the tourism economy can build stable lives from the wealth they help generate. Whether local people feel included in the future of their own city.
A city that forgets whom it belongs to may still be beautiful, but it has already begun to disappear.