Odds: Stacked or Not Load-Bearing?

Are the odds really stacked against people?

When I was younger, the answer felt like an obvious yes.
The older, or perhaps simply more informed, I’ve become, the answer feels more complicated.

I imagined public and institutional power (governments, regulators, large orgs) as one well-coordinated, impenetrable wall. The people at the top had power and everybody else existed underneath it. That was all.

But the wall isn’t nearly as cohesive as I thought. There are competing incentives, dependencies, rivalries, jurisdictions and political cycles, all complicated by bureaucratic incompetence and organisations undermining one another. Once I began understanding those seams, strategic literacy became useful. Understanding how systems actually function opens up a few doors.

Side note:

Part of me wonders why manoeuvring any of this should even be necessary.
A) Public institutions ostensibly exist to represent the public.
B) I am supposedly a free human being with agency over my own life.

Why exactly should I need to become strategically literate in institutional incentives simply to retain some autonomy? But I don’t want to thwart my fleeting thoughts by disappearing down a different philosophical rabbit hole.

Back to the odds.

I think there’s an important distinction between recognising that the odds are structurally stacked and internalising the idea that I’m therefore powerless. Those aren’t the same thing. People have always found seams.

Voice

Fred Hampton. A young man who somehow managed to organise deprived communities, build unlikely coalitions and create enough momentum that powerful institutions were like, “Yo, this guy is wildin fam’”. Or probably more like “I don’t like the cut of his jib”.

Fred was eventually killed. He was 21 btw. But my point is that he still managed to organise. And rally people. Despite the enormous systemic suppression, an individual could create enough force to disturb the machinery of power.

That’s one form of agency. Trying to change the system itself. Then there are other versions, such as finding another system.

Exit

In the UK, people operating small companies once had relatively favourable ways of extracting income after corporation tax was paid. Over time, these ways became less favourable while costs rose.

If someone has the mobility (there are privilege hierarchies in agency too, but I won’t go down that side quest today either), there may be options to geo-arbitrage. Something that companies do constantly – setting up entities in tax-neutral jurisdictions.

Countries want tax revenue, and they compete for residents, capital, businesses and talent. Meaning there isn’t really one unified “top” power structure. There are lots of tops, often competing with one another. And those conflicts create openings.

Side note: I’m not making a moral argument for or against any particular tax arrangement here. The interesting thing is that these choices exist at all.
If businesses can shop around for labour, regulation and tax advantages, individuals shouldn’t feel guilty for doing their own version of the same thing.

Overall

So perhaps the odds are stacked. But stacked ≠ predetermined.
The system can constrain available moves while still leaving other moves available. Sometimes retaining agency means noticing two powerful institutions that want different things and quietly walking the gap between them. So those institutions are still powerful AF. Just nowhere near as almighty as they first appeared.

That’s probably what’s changed in my thinking. Power is real, but power is fragmented. And fragmentation creates manoeuvring room. Learning where that room exists is itself a form of agency.

Headlights by In Color

I really liked the lyric, “You know you look so pretty when you say I’m not the one.”

It hit a nerve.

So I’ve had the song on repeat for days now. While cooking. While showering. On my way to the Asian store for coconut cream. Wiping dust off my Calathea leaves.

Eventually I started making up my own lyrics, just to make the song last a little longer:

You leave your earrings sleeping by my glass,
then tell me not to read too much in that.
You kiss me slow, then slip out of my grasp,
say, “don’t make this more than what we have.”
You know you look so pretty when you say I’m not the one,
I wish I could believe you and be done.

Rain made little galaxies on your coat,
I watched them blur like words I never wrote,
I heard your tires whisper down the road.
Your earrings still sit beside my empty glass,
catching headlights every time they pass.

26 Years Ago….on Intelligent Machines


Perhaps it is always hard to see the bigger impact while you are in the vortex of a change. Failing to understand the consequences of our inventions while we are in the rapture of discovery and innovation seems to be a common fault of scientists and technologists; we have long been driven by the overarching desire to know that is the nature of science’s quest, not stopping to notice that the progress to newer and more powerful technologies can take on a life of its own.

Bill Joy. (2000) ‘Why the Future Doesn’t Need Us’, Wired, 1 April. Available at: https://www.wired.com/2000/04/joy-2/

Nick Cave and The Bad Seeds

People send in questions to Nick Cave, and it’s easy to recognise what kind of man is writing back.

Agustina from Argentina asked: How do I make my partner not the centre of my world?

Nick:
I am not the one to advise on how to keep love at a sensible distance, Agustina. Against the advice of an army of therapists, analysts, 12-step sponsors, life-coaches, hypnotists and TED Talkers, my wife and I remain committed to full-on emotional enmeshment, a massive dose of co-dependency, some good old maladaptive caretaking, and a fair amount of enslavement. I am a happy planet helplessly orbiting my wife, the sun; I am her vassal, her monkey on a chain, in her thrall, drunk on her, lost to her. I suspect if you asked her, she’d say she’s the planet, and I’m the sun, but that would be her being modest. Whatever the case, we are better together and a mess apart, fully entangled, all in, happily doomed. By the way, there was an eclipse last night, marking, amongst other things, twenty-seven years of our marriage. How thoughtful of the cosmos to have remembered.

(Source)

Substack

I’ve been encouraged to post on Substack for years. I tried it again recently, and somehow it felt worse than the last time.

I don’t entirely trust myself to remain untouched by the incentive structure surrounding me. The engagement metrics, the comments, the awareness of which posts do “well”…the risk of it shaping my writing in ways I might never notice.

I want a little quiet corner of the internet instead. Somewhere my mind can wander freely. Somewhere nobody is rewarding me for becoming any particular version of myself.

Sorry.

Dry With Dark Undertones

Friend: ..just when I think I’ve got you figured out, you surprise me again

Me: Friendship with me is like a fine wine

Friend: Better with age?

Me: No. Best kept locked in the basement

Cinemateca

The Last Picture Show was on at Cinemateca.

I got into an Uber wearing loose trousers, in case the old theatre didn’t have AC.

While we were driving, Portuguese radio was playing, and I realised I could understand many of the words. But not quickly enough to assemble them into a complete thought.

(Note: All conversations were actually in Portuguese.)

Me: What radio station is this?

Driver: [throws a sceptical look in the rearview mirror and says something quietly]

Me: Pardon?

Driver: It’s Observador.

Me: Ah, thanks. I could really use this to help my Portuguese.

His face warms into a smile, followed by a mildly surprised little laugh.

I get to Cinemateca. There’s an older woman being served at the front desk.

After a few minutes of waiting, I realise there’s a bead of sweat rolling down my face. My calculations failed me. I walked too fast. 

I wipe it away and turn around to check if I can catch a breeze from the doors behind me.

Instead, I turn directly into the face of a woman.

This startles both of us.

I’m too hot to be socially functional, so I turn back around and become a statue, hoping the entire incident disappears.

A few minutes later, the guy at the front desk looks over the elderly woman he’s serving and says something to me very quickly. I understood nothing.

Me: Uh… I already have a ticket. Can I just go ahead to the screen?

Him: Of course. You don’t need to wait here.

Excellent.

I start down a long, shadowy hallway looking for the screening room. I notice the woman who had been behind me in the queue is now literally just behind me again.

Me: Do you know where the screen is?

Her: Back and to the left, I think.

We eventually find the security guy outside. He has a scanner and is holding intense eye contact. No words. He must want a QR code. The woman behind me reaches a different conclusion and tries to walk in. The security guard places his arm against the doorway. 

Her: Oh, can’t I buy tickets here? I didn’t want to keep waiting at the front desk. It’d take forever.

Me: I have a spare one if you’d like.

Her: Ah, let me give you the cash.

Me: No need. It’s a spare.

Her: You bought it by accident?

Me: I always buy two tickets to things. Just to tempt fate.

Her: …

We go in and split ways.

She takes one of the easily accessible seats. I spot an empty one further up, which requires making several people stand up to let me through.

High effort. High reward.

It’s a great seat.

I settle in, beads of sweat still forming on my forehead. I stay as still as possible to prevent attracting further attention.

A few minutes later, I notice people in my row passing coins, stacked between their thumb and index fingers, towards me from the other side.

“It’s from some lady” says the man sitting nearby.